Okay it gets weirder. After many tries with many different remote directories, I finally changed my settings to something that Auction Wizard liked:
remote directory: /usr/local/apache/htdocs/
http address: http://www.lionrhod.com

However the program didn't actually upload the files. What is really strange about this, is that when I put in my http address WITHOUTH the remote directory, AW DID upload the files, but it was uploaded to a directory BEFORE the remote directory which is not accessible from the web.

This is what I get for trying to figure out a program during mercury retrograde.

Lion